That Friday night, three Islamic State commandos strike Paris and Saint-Denis: outside the Stade de France, café terraces in the 10th and 11th arrondissements, and the Bataclan concert hall. 130 people are killed, 90 of them at the Bataclan, during a rock concert. The next day, the Islamic State claims the attacks and calls Paris the "capital of abominations and perversion". The only surviving attacker, Salah Abdeslam, was sentenced to whole-life imprisonment on June 29, 2022, at the end of the V13 trial.
That Saturday morning, Hamas commandos break through the Gaza fence. They attack a music festival, kibbutzim, towns. More than 1,200 people are killed, according to AFP. At the Nova festival, 364 young people are shot dead. 251 people are taken to Gaza as hostages. Among the dead are 51 French citizens, according to the French Foreign Ministry.
The target is the same: young people dancing. The Bataclan and Nova were both celebrations.
## After the Bataclan, a country that stood together
Six days after the attacks, on November 19, 2015, the French National Assembly extends the state of emergency by three months: 551 votes for, 6 against, one abstention. The state of emergency is open to debate. The vote says something else: faced with the massacre, the nation's representatives stood together.
The vote says something else: faced with the massacre, the nation's representatives stood together.
## After Nova, a missing word
On October 7, 2023, the same day, the parliamentary group of La France Insoumise (LFI), Jean-Luc Mélenchon's far-left party, issues a statement. It speaks of an "armed offensive by Palestinian forces led by Hamas", in a context of "intensifying Israeli occupation policy". The word "terrorist" does not appear. That day, every French political force condemns the attack; LFI is alone in refusing to call Hamas "terrorist". Léon Deffontaines of the Communist Party, an LFI ally, calls the statement "a disgrace".
On October 17, on Sud Radio, LFI lawmaker Danièle Obono, pressed by Jean-Jacques Bourdin, answers: "Yes, Hamas is a resistance movement." The Interior Minister refers her to prosecutors for condoning terrorism. Obono has since announced that the referral was dropped; prosecutors have not publicly confirmed it.
In June 2026, outside the Paris courthouse, Jean-Luc Mélenchon backs an activist prosecuted for condoning terrorism. He rejects the idea that there are "among us people who would rejoice in terrorism", and adds: "assuming the acts in question really are terrorism". He goes on to say that LFI's position "never meant that we approve of this or that method of combat, especially when it involves defenceless civilians". We quote that sentence too, because it is part of what he said. Three French victims of October 7 have filed a complaint against him for condoning terrorism.
Hamas, including its armed wing, is on the European Union's list of terrorist organisations. On February 7, 2024, France held a national tribute at Les Invalides to the French victims of the "terrorist attacks of October 7".
The Bataclan was terrorism. So was Nova.
*Quotes translated from French. Sources: V13 trial; AFP; French Foreign Ministry; French National Assembly, vote of November 19, 2015; Politis and Le Monde, October 7, 2023; Sud Radio and LCP, October 17, 2023; AFP, June 26, 2026; Élysée, February 7, 2024.*