Midbar
← Back
Culture

The story of the Jewish people, part 3: twenty centuries without a state

Third episode. For eighteen centuries Jews live everywhere and govern nowhere: no army, no border, no king. The Mishnah and then the Talmud pack a civilisation into books you can carry. Babylon, Cordoba, Mainz, Krakow: every time a community settles, prospers, and one day is told to leave. 1096, 1290, 1306, 1492. And every year, the same sentence: next year in Jerusalem.

·Source: Midbar

*Third episode of a five-part series on the story of the Jewish people.*

From the end of the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 to the creation of Israel in 1948, eighteen centuries pass. All that time, Jews live everywhere and govern nowhere.

## The portable library

Around the year 200, the oral law is written down: the Mishnah. Around 500, the Babylonian Talmud is closed. Thousands of pages of argument, and not a catechism: the minority opinion is preserved next to the ruling.

From one end of the known world to the other, letters travel with the merchants. A community asks, an academy answers, and the answer becomes precedent a thousand miles away.

## One community, then another

Babylon, Alexandria, Rome. Then Cordoba, where they write in Arabic and in Hebrew, until the Almohads force conversion and Maimonides flees to Egypt. Then Mainz, then Krakow. Every time the same motion: they settle, they prosper, and one day they are told to leave.

Every time the same motion: they settle, they prosper, and one day they are told to leave.

1096: on their way to Jerusalem, the crusaders massacre the Rhineland communities. 1290: England expels its Jews. 1306: France expels its own. 1492: Spain, after a thousand years. Portugal follows in 1497.

## Four months

The Granada decree of 31 March 1492 gives four months to sell, to leave or to convert. The Sephardim carry their language, Ladino, to Salonica, Istanbul and Fez, where they will still speak it four centuries later.

## The move east

Meanwhile Poland takes them in and grants charters, from the Statute of Kalisz in 1264 to Casimir III in 1334. The census of 1764 counts about 750,000 Jews in Poland-Lithuania. The centre of Jewish Europe has moved east, and stays there until the twentieth century.

## What holds

How does a people hold on without a state? With a language kept for prayer. With a calendar set on the seasons of a country they no longer live in: they ask for the rain of Judea from Poland. And with a sentence repeated every year by people who had never been there: next year in Jerusalem.

#JewishHistory#Talmud#Sephardi#Ashkenazi#Diaspora#History#Midbar

Midbar lives on its readers.

No paywall, no account, no tracker. Your support, once or every month, funds what you just read.

Support Midbar

Read next

The story of the Jewish people, part 3: twenty centuries without a state | Midbar