Midbar
← Back
Israel

"Negotiate": The Word Nobody Expected on the Haredi Draft

According to The Times of Israel, Gadi Eisenkot and Avigdor Liberman say they are ready to negotiate with the haredi parties on the conscription law. Details are still scarce. But the choice of that verb, on day one of a 28-day mandate, says something about a country that three years of war have changed.

The facts fit on a single line, and that is already a great deal. According to The Times of Israel, Gadi Eisenkot, tasked since Sunday by President Isaac Herzog with forming the next government, and Avigdor Liberman say they are ready to negotiate with the haredi parties on the conscription law. At this hour we do not have the details of the proposals, the timetable, or the response of the parties concerned. We will not make them up.

But the verb is there: negotiate. It comes from two men the Israeli press has for years counted among the firmest voices on sharing the burden of military service. That they are opening the door to dialogue with the haredi parties, at the very start of a 28-day mandate, is not a footnote in coalition horse-trading. It is a choice of method.

Because other methods existed. One could have waited for a court ruling, issued an ultimatum, pushed a law through on the thinnest of majorities against part of the country. Choosing to sit at the same table means recognizing that the other side has something to defend, and that it will still be there tomorrow.

And what each side defends is legitimate. The world of the yeshivot carries Torah study, the study that held the Jewish people together for twenty centuries without a state or an army, and that one generation rebuilt in Israel after the Shoah destroyed its centers in Europe. The reservists, for their part, are coming home from three years of war with a simple demand: that the weight be carried on more shoulders. A haredi from Bnei Brak and a reservist from Tel Aviv are not defending two countries. They are defending the same one, through two doors.

A haredi from Bnei Brak and a reservist from Tel Aviv are not defending two countries.

What holds them together is greater than what divides them: the safety of the same children, the continuity of the same people, the attachment to the same land. The conscription law is not a debate about belonging. It is a debate about how to serve. And you only negotiate with those you cannot do without.

A word about vocabulary, because it matters. The Times of Israel headline speaks of the "ultra-Orthodox." The word is not theirs. They call themselves haredim, "those who tremble" before the word of God. Calling people by the name they give themselves is the first act of any negotiation, and Midbar holds to it.

Then there is the angle so often missed from the diaspora. We read this file through imported lenses: secularism against religion, the state against the community. They do not work here. Eisenkot and Liberman are not asking the haredim to believe less: they are asking them to share a burden. And the haredi parties are not asking Israel to stop being a state: they are asking it to protect a form of study without which it would have had no people to gather. This is not a clash of values. It is a contract to be written between the two halves of a single inheritance, the one that kept the book and the one that took back the land.

Twenty-eight days is short for a contract like that. Nothing says it will be signed this time. But a country coming out of three years of war, whose leaders choose, on the most sensitive subject of all, to talk rather than to cut, shows what keeps it standing. Unity is not an election-night slogan. It is a table you agree to sit down at.

#Israel#Eisenkot#Knesset#Haredim#IDF#JewishNews#JewishUnity#Midbar

Midbar lives on its readers.

No paywall, no account, no tracker. Your support, once or every month, funds what you just read.

Support Midbar

Read next

"Negotiate": The Word Nobody Expected on the Haredi Draft | Midbar