Midbar
← Back
Israel

Fly and Vote: Likud Tries to Ground the Expats Flying Home to Vote, and Both Camps Are Defending the Same Zionist Principle Without Realizing It

Likud petitioned the Central Elections Committee on Wednesday to shut down the programs helping Israelis abroad fly home to vote on October 27. The French daily 20 Minutes calls it an "anti-democratic power grab." It is a petition before a judge. And it directly concerns thousands of Midbar readers.

·Source: 20 Minutes

The facts first. On Wednesday, attorney Ilan Bombach, acting on behalf of Likud, filed a petition with the chairman of the Central Elections Committee, Justice Noam Solberg. It asks him to halt the initiatives that help expatriate Israelis return home to vote on October 27: discounted fares negotiated through group bookings, help with paperwork, shuttles from the airport. Two targets are named: Aid Coalition, an American organization opposed to the outgoing government that runs the "Fly and Vote" program, and the opposition party The Democrats. For Likud, these fares amount to an "electoral bribe" and violate the Party Financing Law. Back in late August, it was already accusing the operation of undermining "the authenticity of the vote."

The Central Bureau of Statistics counts 600,000 Israelis living outside the country. The law does not allow them to vote from abroad, apart from consular staff. Michal Dagon, who heads the project, recently told Haaretz that more than 30,000 people had registered, against a target of 50,000 to 70,000 voters. In an election the polls call tight between Benjamin Netanyahu's bloc and Gadi Eisenkot's, that is no footnote.

First thing to set straight: 20 Minutes opens with an "anti-democratic power grab." A written petition, filed before a committee chaired by a judge who will rule according to the law, is the exact opposite of a power grab. Likud's argument is weak, since the travelers pay for their own tickets. But the Party Financing Law exists precisely to regulate benefits in kind, and an American organization arranging group flights toward a national election deserves, at the very least, a look. If an American foundation close to Likud were doing the same thing for right-wing voters, the opposition would be at Justice Solberg's door the same day.

Second point: Likud is betting that these expatriates vote against it. Nothing proves that. Those coming home are, in Aid Coalition's words, "citizens who came to fight on October 7, who pay taxes and are involved in the life of their homeland." That kind of electorate is not to be presumed; it is to be won over. A party that would rather block an airport than campaign in the diaspora is saying something to those still hesitating to come home.

Second point: Likud is betting that these expatriates vote against it.

And here is what neither camp has noticed. Israeli law refuses the remote ballot. That is not a loophole, it is a principle: the country's fate is decided by those who live under its sirens, do their reserve duty and pay their taxes on the ground. Yet "Fly and Vote" does not challenge that principle. Nobody is demanding a polling station in Paris or Brooklyn; people are being asked to set foot on the land in order to have a say. By organizing these flights, the opposition is ratifying the most Zionist idea there is: Israeli citizenship is exercised in Israel.

For Midbar readers, this is not a distant story. Thousands of French Israelis keep that blue passport in a drawer. Justice Solberg will decide whether a negotiated fare is an unlawful benefit. Whatever his ruling, 50,000 Israelis landing at Ben Gurion to cast a ballot looks less like an electoral maneuver than a dress rehearsal for return. Some of them, once there, will miss the flight back. No petition will change that.

#Israel#IsraelElections#Knesset#Likud#Eisenkot#Netanyahu#FlyAndVote#JewishNews#Aliyah#Midbar

Read next